Every web agency is expected to say the same thing about Wix, Squarespace and Shopify: that they're rubbish, that you get what you pay for, that a proper website needs a proper developer. We're not going to say that, because it isn't true.
Some of these builders are very good. For plenty of businesses, one of them is exactly the right answer. The tool was never the problem.
Think of it like a flat-pack wardrobe. It's a perfectly good product, well engineered, does what it says on the box. It still needs someone to give up a Saturday, read the instructions properly, notice that panel C has gone in backwards, and drive back to the shop for the bracket that was missing from the bag. Nobody blames the wardrobe for that. The wardrobe did its job. The person assembling it made the decisions, good and bad, that determined how it turned out.
Websites work the same way. What you're actually paying for when you hire an agency isn't better software than you could buy yourself. It's a long list of decisions made once, made properly, by someone who has made them several hundred times before.
The decisions nobody tells you to make
Every page on a website needs a job. Not a vague sense of "this is where the about bit goes", but an actual purpose: what should the person reading this do next, and what happens if they don't.
The words matter more than the design, and most businesses get this backwards. They'll agonise over a colour palette and then fill every page with the same three paragraphs about being "passionate" and "customer-focused", which tells a visitor nothing and ranks for nothing either.
Photos either earn their place or they're dead weight slowing the page down. Stock images of people shaking hands in an office nobody has ever worked in are the digital equivalent of the hotel art nobody looks at twice.
Then there's the unglamorous plumbing: what happens to the old page addresses when the site gets rebuilt. Get this wrong and years of search ranking, built up slowly and expensively, vanishes in a weekend because nobody set up the redirects. We've rescued more than one business from exactly this after a well-meaning DIY rebuild.
Mobile data, rain, and the form nobody checks
Most traffic to most small business websites now arrives on a phone, often outside, often on patchy signal, sometimes genuinely in the rain because somebody is standing in a car park trying to find an opening time. A site that only looks good on a widescreen monitor in a warm office has already failed most of its visitors before they've read a word.
And then there's the enquiry form. Businesses spend money getting someone to that form, then never check where the submissions actually go. We've seen forms quietly emailing an address that was deleted two staff changes ago. Nobody noticed because nobody was looking for enquiries that weren't arriving.
Backups are the same story. Everyone assumes they exist. Far fewer people have actually tried restoring one, which is the only way to find out whether it works.
None of this requires an agency, strictly speaking
All of it is doable alone. It's roughly a fortnight of evenings and somewhere around forty small decisions: page by page, word by word, bracket by bracket. The honest question isn't whether a business owner could do this themselves. Plenty could, and some do it well.
The real question is whether those evenings are worth more spent somewhere else: on the business itself, on clients, on the thing that actually pays the bills. An agency doesn't sell better software. It sells the forty decisions already made correctly, by someone who has made them enough times to know where the panel usually goes in backwards.
What this means for choosing between DIY and an agency
There's no universal right answer here, and we'd rather say that plainly than pretend otherwise for the sake of a sales pitch. A simple, low-stakes site for a small local business might genuinely be better built on a template, by the owner, on a quiet Sunday. A site that's meant to generate enquiries, rank for competitive search terms, and represent a growing business probably isn't the place to learn forty new skills at once while also running that business.
We've built websites across just about every sector over 25 years, from Devon and Tiverton out to clients working internationally through our Dubai office, and the pattern repeats regardless of industry: the businesses that struggle online rarely struggle because of the software they chose. They struggle because nobody made the decisions properly, or nobody made them at all.
If it's worth figuring out which category a project falls into before spending a fortnight of evenings on it, our web development services are a reasonable place to start that conversation, or simply book a call and we'll tell it to you straight.